Tuesday, 22 May 2012

Episode 14 - Hybrid Bearings

Download episode 14 by right clicking and saving as... (below)


In this episode

               Hybrid bearings

Thanks for joining me for the 14th episode of the Australian Power Transmission Podcast, one of the top twenty podcasts devoted to the mechanical power transmission industry.  I can say that with some authority, as I’m not sure exactly how many other PT podcasts there are out there.  In fact, I can’t find any others, so this one must at least be in the top 20.

It is Monday, May 21st, 2012.  My name is Damian Harris and I’m coming to you from a cold Melbourne.

*Germany has long attracted the best engineers in the world for its industrial manufacturing efforts, coming from different places at different times.  For the past half-decade, it is China who has provided a bevy of industrial engineering talent, trained domestically, aware of Western manufacturing demands and very attractive to the best companies.  Well, more and more, China wants them back.

Hanover Messe’s recent occurrence brought into sharp focus just how quickly Chinese manufacturers are catching the West, not so much in quality but definitely in ingenuity.  Many of these manufacturers happen to be subsidiaries of Western multinationals, but many aren’t.  Increasingly, the wages earned for engineers in China is climbing, with the gap to Europe steadily closing.  The Germans know that its status at the top of the industrial engineering tree is reliant upon maintaining the cream of the engineering human resource.  How much more will it cost each year to retain this supremacy?   

*Timken’s earnings climbed 38% for Q1, citing an increase in demand for its four core product offerings: process industries, mobile industries, aerospace and defence, and steel.  Sales for the quarter were $1.42 billion, with net income $155 million. 

A significant portion of the growth in revenue can also be attributed to Timken’s strategic acquisition policy, which has added numerous businesses to the process industries portfolio and we are beginning to see the benefits realised.

*As predicted by the Australian Power Transmission Podcast – as well as every media outlet in Australia – QANTAS has announced the closure of its Melbourne maintenance facility, consolidating both Brisbane and Melbourne’s Avalon workshops.  Efforts by unions to limit the impact have eventually come to nought, although even they were probably aware they were on a hiding to nothing.

Overall job losses from the closure at Tullamarine amount to 422.  Some positions have been made available at the other facilities but there seems to be limited take-up.

*Hansen Industrial Transmissions is set to incorporate maintenance activities for the Paramax range of gearboxes from new parent Sumitomo into its European assembly centre in Antwerp.  Sumitomo Heavy Industries acquired Hansen last year, and the rationalisation of resources such as this is an obvious move.  Sumitomo and Hansen also have service centre overlap in other jurisdictions and product ranges that are somewhat complimentary.  It would make sense if further rationalisation efforts were on the agenda.

*Something from South Africa is the fifth annual PneuDrive Challenge, aimed at bridging the gap between businesses and engineering students.  Sponsored by Festo and SEW, the PneuDrive Challenge is a travelling road show which will visit universities throughout the republic and put students through their paces.

The theme for competitors for 2012 is ‘Engineering a Better Life for Communities in South Africa’, which tests students across a range of disciplines and with a number of specific outcomes, from economic viability and energy efficiency right through to relevance to South Africa’s broader community demands.   

If nothing else, for their investment Festo and SEW get their products in the heads and hands of South Africa’s next generation of design engineers, as well as scout some of the talent that will soon be in the employment pool. 

*Like it or loathe it, junk mail is a fact of life.  Direct marketers love it, and it comes as a shock to hear that printing and distribution company PMP has issued profit warnings, sending its share price tumbling, only to see it take off again after rumours of an acquisition hit the market.

PMP’s main revenue stream is junk mail, and direct marketing companies have all experienced the same downturn in demand experienced by advertisers operating in other markets.

*CSR’s new Gyprock facility in Yarraville was opened by Victorian Premier Ted Baillieu on the 9th of May.  The total investment by CSR is $160M, and employs 160 in the manufacture of plaster sheeting used domestically in the housing construction sector.

*SKF has opened its first Solution Factory in Australia, with Perth selected because it is the closest capital city to the heart of the mining industry.  It is the 18th such Solution Factory in the world and implies that other SKF sites cannot solve problems, but actually refers to the broad range of products and services offered; bearings, seals, services, lubrication systems and mechatronics.

*ABB Australia has acquired Bob White Electrix and LE Jarvis, both electric motor rewinders and manufacturers, for an undisclosed sum in a deal is expected to be completed in July.

The Geelong-based Bob White Electrix started in 1946 and has grown to handle a capacity of 85 tonne rotors in its balancing pit.  LE Jarvis opened its doors in 1967 in Perth and now boasts 25 staff, handling a broad range of applications itself.

ABB is serious about increasing its capacity, with growth through acquisitions dominating their last 24 months, so much so that consistent purchases in the US now make that market ABB’s biggest.

One potential conflict from the acquisition of LE Jarvis that will need to be addressed in the fact that Jarvis is a WEG distributor and test/repair facility.  I’m not sure how WEG sits with the ABB purchase.

*The maker of Devondale butter has already had some layoffs this year, but unfortunately is due for another round.  Murray Goulburn is matching its business with the demands of the market, which has seen global prices drop on the back of significant milk oversupply.

300 staff will be made redundant, with around 60 coming from head office and the balance in processing and distribution, in a move that represents a further 12% of the total Murray Goulburn workforce.

*Development in materials technology will always be the way forward in pushing for more performance out of existing designs.  The alloying of metals for gears, shafts and rolling elements has always lead the way, with composites also becoming more important for larger components.  In a vicious circle, the more performance derived from a design, the more that is demanded by future applications.

In extreme applications (such as bearings in gas turbines and for man’s adventures into space… the final frontier), ceramics have become increasingly popular, mainly because they are the only thing that can do the job.  Known as hybrid bearings because the rolling elements are ceramic whilst the bearing retainer, inner ring and outer ring are made out of metal, they can withstand the extremes of temperature generated by high speeds.

Further to high speed applications and the thermals involved in turbines (which frequently average more than 30,000 RPM and 600 degrees Celcius, the gases themselves are very hot - we are talking temperatures over 1100 degrees Celcius.

For the most part, it is the demands of jet engine development that have driven development of ceramics, with engineers looking to capitalise on their temperature characteristics and low weight when used in bearing form.  There is an obvious drawback in ceramic material which has been the focus of development, in that it can be considered weak and brittle when compared with some specialist alloys that can perform a similar role but just can’t handle the temperature.  Additionally, ceramics are not readily receptive to secondary-process machining.

Bearing grade silicon nitride, Si3N4, is the current standard material for ceramic rolling bearings, which enables design engineers and manufacturers across the globe to specify a known quantity with confidence.  This also assists global R&D efforts.  Hot Isostatic Pressed silicon nitride features self-reinforcing properties, where its two ceramic phases; alpha-silicon nitride and beta-silicon nitride, have different crystal shapes.  R&D has focused on matching alpha and beta to increase strength and toughness.

The elevated temperatures that silicon bearings are asked to operate in naturally call upon special lubrication.  In most cases, the lubricant used is solid, with a very high melting point, not unlike the moulded oil bearings marketed by NSK.  There are no other issues with the lubricant affecting the silicon.

Ceramic hybrid bearings are going to feature more prominently in high-value and high-performance applications, as development and increased usage bring about higher quantities in operation.  Ceramics will also feature in other applications as the bearing development knowledge filters through to other areas in engineering.   
That’s it for episode 14 of the Australian Power Transmission Podcast. 

If you’d like to contact the show, send me an email.  feedback@australianptpodcast.com.

Follow me on twitter @ozptpodcast.
Visit the show’s website, www.australianptpodcast.com.

I’m Damian Harris.  I appreciate you taking the time to listen, and I’ll catch you again in two weeks.

Episode 14 - Play it right here, right now

Monday, 7 May 2012

Episode 13 - Superfinishing of Gears, Ordering Methods

http://traffic.libsyn.com/australianptpodcast/ep13ozpt.mp3


Episode 13 of the Australian Power Transmission Podcast

In this episode

                How do your orders come, and

                Superfinishing of gears

Welcome to the thirteenth episode of the Australian Power Transmission Podcast.  You’re listening to Damian Harris, coming to you from Melbourne on Monday, May 7, 2012.

If you have any comments, complaints or criticism, contact me on twitter @ozptpodcast or via email at feedback@australianptpodcast.com.  I invite you, like I do every show, to go to the show’s website at www.australianptpodcast.com.  It is simple, but it’s also straightforward and honest.

*The ownership of Australian and New Zealand SKF Distributorship has changed hands, with Ohio-based Applied Industrial Technologies purchasing the business from SKF direct.

Applied is a specialist in MRO industrial supply, with four and a half thousand employees and turnover of $2.2 billion.

In Australia, SKF has operated with a hub and spoke distributorship philosophy.  Many of the branches carry the bare minimum of stock and the main distribution centre carries the bulk.  I wonder if there will be any change in business model with the purchase.

*The 2012 Hannover Fair saw ABB launching what they claim to be the world’s first IE4 efficiency motors, in a size range of 75kW to 375kW.  ABB is using the term ‘super-premium’ for this new range of 3 phase motors, claiming they are best suited to S1 duty, where a reduction in CO2 results from higher efficiency.

*Modest by comparison with Hannover but still substantial nonetheless, Mach 2012 at the Birmingham NEC took place in mid-April and received positive reviews.  Manufacturing in the UK is in the same boat as many of the world’s developed nations, struggling with high wages, decreasing exports and an ageing workforce.  I am a strong believer in conferences of this nature having a constructive outcome.

*Japanese motor manufacturer Nidec is digging deep into its pockets to purchase the Italian motors and drives manufacturer, Ansaldo Sistemi Industriali, or (ASI).  The money involved for the purchase is thought to be in the region of $400M - $500M.

Among Nidec Corporation's primary products are ultra-high-precision spindle motors for hard disk drives, whilst ASI boasts a full suite of industrial motor manufacturing technology, making it an attractive acquisition for Nidec. 

The purchase moves Nidec into new markets and product ranges, with ASI manufacturing motors right up to 25,000kW, in low and medium voltage.

*Meanwhile, Ametek Corporation is purchasing the German motion control outfit, Dunkermotoren GmbH, subject to German government approval.  Dunkermotoren is presently owned by the venture capitalists Triton, whose industrial investment stable includes Dematic and Stabilus.

Amatek has an annual turnover of more than $3 billion, and while the Dunkermotoren acquisition is for an undisclosed sum, the Bonndorf firm is on track for 2012 revenue of $200 million.  Dunkermotoren, who last July themselves acquired London’s Copley Motor Systems, is a specialist in automation using servo equipment.

*The failure of Australian car components manufacturer CMI Industrial has resulted in Ford having to shut its production lines and send workers home for a week.

CMI – who manufacture a range of components including suspension and exhaust parts - appointed McgrathNicol as administrators last week, as the firm struggled to pay its debts as and when they fell due.

The Toyota Production System and Just In Time have become universal in the automotive manufacturing world, as evidenced by the announcement by CMI, which was followed the next day by the announcement of Ford’s shutdown.  Only one day, how LEAN can you get?

For the purposes of full disclosure, one of the CMI businesses is a customer of mine in my day job.

*Brazilian electric motor manufacturer WEG markets the W22 IP65 and W21 IP55 series of motors the world over, and has added to this with the W22X range of flameproofs.  Aimed at the mining industry with a range starting at 160kW and going through to 1500kW, the W22X has been dual ATEX/IECEx certified for suitability in all markets.

*A recent report by market analyst Frost & Sullivan claims that the European market for integrated motors and drives will expand at a compounded annual growth rate of 12.1% over the seven years 2010 to 2017, from $285 million to $633 million.

This analysis makes sense, especially when you consider that governments the world over are looking to mandate increased motor efficiency levels and yet leave loopholes open for integrated units.  WEG’s recent Cestari purchase, combined with SEW-Eurodrive, NORD, Bauer and a whole host of American manufacturers will look to continue the push for integral units as planned redundancy also results in greater returns.



 






*Operating in a sales firm, orders come through in many ways and via many channels.  Obviously the telephone still constitutes the bulk of B2B communication, although email has standardised with the new generation of workers.  It is important that customers can find you in the way they want to, which constantly changes.

Email and faxes are used for ordering, quotes, a wealth of standard communication and placing your footy tips.  They serve as a way of creating a hardcopy confirmation of things already said, much in the same way that the postal service used to.  But how did we get to the current state of play?

Many of the old technical catalogues from power transmission and gearing manufacturers feature contact information with something called a telex on it.  The telex predates the fax, looks like a typewriter and works like a typewriter mixed with a pianola.  The telex service in Australia was made fully automatic in 1966 and became the de facto standard for hardcopy B2B communication, holding sway for around 20 years, before the fax took over.

Electronic Data Interchange (or EDI) has also become a standard ordering system in major businesses, streamlining two-way information flow and limiting the scope for error.

All of which leads me to a new business, amazonsupply.com.  The Seattle-based e-commerce business, famous primarily for book sales and its Kindle e-book reader, purchased Small Parts back in 2005.  Small Parts supplies medical and scientific components, and is being used as the springboard of the amazonsupply.com business.

As far as the majority of listeners of the podcast are concerned, amazonsupply.com features a dedicated power transmission section, with Bearings, Springs, Sprockets, Belts, Couplings, Unis, Pulleys, Gears, Shafting, Linear Motion, Gearboxes, Chains, Vibration Control, Lubricants as well as Brakes & Clutches all covered under their own heading.

Key features of amazonsupply.com are a product listing of over 500,000 items, a free 365-day returns policy, free two day shipping for orders over $50.00 and a dedicated customer service centre.  My American friends will have to tell me how good their customer service centre performs.

eBay stores have existed for a while, without radically changing the face of industrial supply.  Web 2.0 has facilitated greater business on the internet, but by necessity this only applies to equipment which can be considered commodities.  Specialist power transmission equipment requires specific knowledge of design requirements, with its inherent subtleties.  Amazon is a little more aggressive with its outlook and will be looking to control as much of the vertical supply chain as possible.




*Gears in industrial geared motors go through a few processes before being ready for action.  After being cut and heat treated, added life and strength is gained from finishing.  It is this gear finishing that I am interested in.

Most manufacturers have arrived at precision grinding as the best way to add strength in a cost-effective manner for volume applications.  The process basically involves using an abrasive to reduce high points on the tooth face.  Overcoming friction is one of the key requirements of the tooth finishing process, ensuring lubricant is given enough scope to do its job properly.

Critical or high-performance applications such as aerospace, motor racing and power generation require gears that can handle the required torque, but do it with higher efficiency and less heat.  There is one finishing technique called isotropic superfinishing that is well worth following up on.   

The best way to summarise the process is to read verbatim an article by Lane Winkelmann, Paul W. Niskanen & Bruce D. Hansen, which is courtesy Gear Solutions magazine, June 2008.

“The isotropic superfinish is produced in vibratory finishing bowls or tubs.  An active chemistry is used in the vibratory machine in conjunction with high-density, nonabrasive ceramic media.  When introduced into the machine this active chemistry produces a stable, soft conversion coating on the surface of the metal gears being processed.  The rubbing motion across the gears developed by the machine and media effectively wipes the conversion coating off the “peaks” of the gears’ surfaces, but leaves the “valleys” untouched. 

No finishing occurs where media is unable to contact or rub.  The conversion coating is continually reformed and rubbed off during this stage, producing a surface smoothing mechanism.  This process is continued in the vibratory machine until the surfaces of the gears are free of asperities or until the surface attains the desired level of finish.  At this point the active chemistry is rinsed from the part and the gears are dipped in rust preventive.”

Isotropic superfinishing carries the claim by its proponents that it can increase gear capacity by 30 percent, whilst simultaneously increasing durability by a factor of 3. 

Superfinishing is not a cheap undertaking and is not suitable for everyday manufactured gearboxes, however it would appear that it is getting more popular and may become standardised as manufacturers look to squeeze more performance out of smaller applications.

Thank you for listening to the thirteenth episode of the Australian Power Transmission Podcast. 

I’m Damian Harris and I appreciate the fact that you’ve taken the time to tune in.  I invite you to tune in again in two weeks.

Episode 13 - Play it in the browser